Thanks for Visiting!

Register for free to get the full story.

Sign Up
Already have a Placer.ai account? Log In
Dining

Cookie Chains: Baking It Up A Notch

Find out how cookie chains like Crumbl and Insomnia are doing ahead of the new year.

By 
Bracha Arnold
December 30, 2024
Cookie Chains: Baking It Up A Notch
SHARE
Explore our free tools to get timely insights into key industries
Check out the latest trends for
Key Takeaways
  • Visits to segment leaders Crumbl and Insomnia Cookies remained strong in 2024, with average visits per location in Q3 2024 elevated year-over-year (YoY) by 26.9% and 1.6%, respectively. 
  • Newer chains Crave Cookies, Dirty Dough, Chip Cookies, and Chip City Cookies are also seeing growth – YoY traffic increased between 1.6% and 72.9% in November 2024. 
  • Most cookie brands analyzed – including Crumbl, Crave Cookies, Dirty Dough, Chip Cookies, and Chip City Cookies – attracted visitors from areas with a higher-income and a larger share of suburban family segments. 
  • Insomnia Cookies stood out for the relatively large share of young professionals and young urban singles in its captured market, as well as the relatively lower HHI in its trade area – perhaps due to its late-night hours and college-student focus.

Cookie-centric bakery chains have been around for decades (think Mrs. Fields in nearly every mall across America). But over the past couple of years, specialty cookie chains began to take off, with major players like Crumbl and Insomnia Cookies, as well as smaller companies such as Crave Cookies, Dirty Dough, Chip Cookies, and Chip City Cookies expanding rapidly. 

We analyzed foot traffic as well as trade area demographic and psychographic makeup to understand the growth opportunities and see what lies ahead for the cookie space in 2025.

Not Crumbling Under Any Pressure

Insomnia Cookies, one of the first companies to innovate in the cookie retail space, is known for its late opening hours and classic cookie flavors. The company started in 2003 by selling fresh-baked cookies to college students and now operates over 300 locations globally. Meanwhile, Crumbl Cookies – known for its celebrity collaborations and intensely loyal social media fanbase – came onto the scene in 2017 and has since grown to over 1,000 franchised locations.  

Both chains are expanding, and diving into the foot traffic data reveals that overall visits as well as average visits per location are still growing for both chains – indicating that the cookie craze is still going strong. 

Craving Cookie Dough

Analyzing visit growth at smaller cookie chains also highlights the strong demand for creative cookie concepts. Crave Cookies (established in 2022), Dirty Dough (2018), Chip Cookies (2016), and Chip City Cookies (2017) are all enjoying strong foot traffic growth relative to 2023, thanks in part to ongoing expansions. Like Crumbl and Insomnia, Crave Cookies, Dirty Dough, Chip Cookies, and Chip City Cookies are all growing their fleet – and the steady stream of store openings has driven consistent YoY visit growth. 

The increasing visits to both the larger chains and the smaller cookie brands suggests that the demand for cookies has yet to peak and is likely to continue in 2025. And with these chains still looking to grow, how can location analytics uncover the best opportunities for growth? 

Cookies Resonate With Higher-Income Families 

A closer look at the demographic makeup of visitors to the analyzed cookie chains suggests that some of these chains’ consistently strong performance may be due to the relative affluence of their consumer base: The STI: PopStats dataset reveals that all of the chains' captured markets – with the exception of Insomnia Cookies – have higher shares of wealthy consumer segments than their potential one. (A chain’s potential market is obtained by weighting each Census Block Group (CBG) in its trade area according to population size, thus reflecting the overall makeup of the chain’s trade area. A business’ captured market, on the other hand, is obtained by weighting each CBG according to its share of visits to the chain in question – and thus represents the profile of its actual visitor base).

Among the analyzed chains, Chip City Cookies attracted visitors from the highest-income areas, with a captured market median HHI of $117.3K – $16.0K higher than its potential market median HHI of $101.3K. Crumbl, Crave, Dirty Dough, Chip, and Chip City also drew visitors from higher-income areas relative to their potential market median HHI.

In contrast, Insomnia Cookies was the only chain with a lower median HHI in its captured market relative to its potential market, likely reflecting its positioning as a late-night snack option for college students.

Suburban Families Favor Cookie Chains

The relatively high-income of cookie consumers may be partially due to the chains’ popularity with suburban segments: According to the Spatial.ai: PersonaLive dataset, almost all the analyzed chains saw a higher share of “Upper Suburban Diverse Families” and “Wealthy Suburban Families” in their captured markets compared to their potential market. Meanwhile, the shares of “Young Urban Singles” and “Young Professionals” were lower across nearly all the analyzed chains’ captured market relative to their potential markets.  

And once again, Insomnia Cookies stood out – the company’s captured market included an outsized share of “Young Professionals” and “Young Urban Singles,” perhaps due to the company's positioning as a late-night college campus favorite.

Taken together, this data suggests that, unless a chain is focused on acquiring a specific audience segment – like Insomnia did when targeting younger, less affluent consumers such as college students – most cookie chains are most likely to thrive in affluent suburban markets. 

To The Last Crumb

The enjoyment provided by a sweet treat is universal – but will these cookie chains retain their edge as the dessert shop market grows increasingly crowded?

Visit Placer.ai to keep up-to-date with the latest data-driven dining insights. 

Learn how downtown regions across US cities are measuring up with our free tools.
Check out the latest trends for
Explore our free tools to get timely insights into key industries
Check out the latest trends for
SHARE
Get 3 brand & industry
breakdowns every week
Subscribe to the newsletter
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Get a Demo

Please enter your first name
Please enter your last name
Please provide a valid email
Please enter your email
Please enter company name

Thanks for reaching out!

One of our experts will be in touch soon

Try Placer.ai Free
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Recent Publications

Get 3 brand & industry breakdowns every week

Subscribe to the newsletter
Text Link
Crumbl Cookies
Text Link
Insomnia Cookies
Text Link
Crave Cookies
Women's Sports on a Roll: Packed Stadiums, The Sports Bra Bar & Restaurant, and Impacting CRE
Year of the Dragon, Luckiest Animal in the Zodiac: Will that Luck Hold for Asian-Themed CRE?
Washington DC: How the Population in Our Nation's Capital has Evolved Following the Pandemic
What First Half 2024 Visit Trends Tell Us About What to Expect in the Second Half
What Does Walmart’s Results Mean for Other Discretionary Retailers?
Warehouse Clubs: Younger Visitors Support Growth
Wayfair: Early Impressions from Wayfair's New Wilmette Store
We're All Mad for March Madness: NCAA Women's Basketball is Breaking All Sorts of Records
Warehouse Clubs: Finding the Perfect Timing
Ulta: A Thing of Beauty
The Sweet Smell of Success: How CPG Brands are Bringing Their Brands to Life with Experiential Stores
Urban Outfitters: High Income, Specialty Fleets Still Thriving
The Silver Lining to Mall Anchor Department Store Closures
Ulta Beauty: Store Visits and Target Partnership Driving Category Market Share
The Secret to Trader Joe's Success in 2023
Tractor Supply: Visitation Share Gains Continue Despite Weather-Related Disruptions
Takeaways from the 2024 Fast Casual Executive Summit
The Lure of Waikiki and Beyond: The Feel of Fifth Avenue on Oahu?
Target: Circle Week Shows Signs of Success
Suiting Up in Boston: Newbury Street Suitsupply Store Showing Signs of Strength
Takeaways from Shoptalk Fall
Stew Leonard’s: Specialty Grocery Still a Shining Example
Small Towns, Deepening Pockets: How Migration is Changing the Face of Boise
Studs: Reinvigorating the Accessories Category
South Asian Influence on Sports, Groceries, and Malls
Starbucks: Silver Linings After a Difficult Quarter
Shopping "High-Low": Escada and Club Monaco share space in Beverly Hills
Round1 Entertainment Expands with Spo-Cha Concept
Self-Storage: More Industry Consolidation Ahead
Self-Storage: Consolidation Driving Year-Over-Year Increases in Visits
Return to Office is Hot in Miami: Placer's New Return to Office Dashboard Launches
Restaurants: Bifurcation Here Too
Self-Storage: More Consolidation as Public Storage Acquires Simply Self Storage
Return to Office Insights: Miami and New York in the Lead
RFDC Takeaways: Lessons from CAVA and Other Restaurant Visit Share Winners
Pop-Ups Drive Excitement and Foretell Brand Demand
Restaurants: Where Do We Stand After Q1 2024
Restaurant Outlook 2024: Year of New Location Expansion Plans?
Reformation: Building an Apparel Destination
Pickleball and Padel: Saviors for Malls, but Threats to Tennis Courts?
Regional Grocery Update: Consumers Seeking Out Lower Prices
QSR Visit Trends: What Gives?
Performing Arts: Takeaways from the California Presenters Conference and Spotlight on Arizona Venues
Public Storage: Self-Storage Demand Resilient
QSR Chicken: Driving the Industry's Growth
Planet Fitness: Signs of a More Resilient Fitness Club Visitor?
Parks, Recreation Centers, and Redeveloped Malls: Community Glue
Outlet Malls: Ontario Mills Leads Black Friday, Arundel Mills Tops November Visitation
Olympics Boost: PR is Priceless
Olympic Inspiration: Is the Fitness Category Bringing Home the Gold?
Outlook for Holiday Thrifting: Inflation, Sustainability, and Gen Z Fuel Growth
Oklahoma, OK!: The Opening of Tulsa Premium Outlets Kickstarts Excitement
"Must-Have" Tenants for 2025: Top Brands to Elevate Your Outdoor Shopping Center
National Restaurant Association Show Takeaways: Who’s Winning the Food Fight?
Non-Traditional Anchors: Cheers or Jeers for Those Replacing Sears?
McDonald's: Where Do Whitespace Opportunities Exist?
Megamalls: All-Day Experiences, Entertainment, and Dining
Mercado Gonzalez: This Mexican Food Hall is a Magnet
Messi Mania hits Miami and LA
Luxury Outlet Malls: Seeing Strong Back-to-School Traffic and the Lure of Luxury
McDonald's: "Adult Happy Meal" Sets a High Bar for QSR Promotions
McDonald’s Swift E. Coli Response Should Minimize Traffic Impact, and SpongeBob’s a Hit at Wendy’s
Measuring the Impact of California’s Minimum Wage Increase on Restaurants
McDonald’s Joins the Restaurant Value Wars of 2024
McDonald’s and the Evolving State of Food Retail
How Have Winter Storms Impacted Retail Visits?
Luxury and Sustainability are the Ethos Driving 1 Hotels
Market Spotlight: How New Mexico Highlights its Cultural and Arts Scene to Drive Business and Leisure Tourism
Marine Layer: "Perfect for a 7-Day Weekend Kinda Lifestyle"
Market Spotlight: Downtown DC Breathes a Sigh of Relief as Washington Wizards and Capitals Stay Put
Kroger/Albertsons: Assessing the Aftershock
Lions and Tigers and Bears, Oh My!: Aquariums and Zoos trends from A to Z
Limited Too: Brand Relaunch Has Millennials in Mind
Let's Get Physical! Fitness Chains in Better Shape to Withstand Economic Volatility
Kohl's + Babies"R"Us: Early Learnings from Newly Opened Michigan Locations
ICSC Takeaways: Retail Optimism, Getting Creative with Formats, Impact of Hybrid/Remote Work, and Miami is Hot
Ikea: Why Invest More in Home Furnishing Retail Now?
In-N-Out Burger: What to Expect as the Brand Moves East
Haunted Car Wash? Tunnel of Terror “Boo”sts traffic by 3x
Hispanic Grocery Chains: Celebrating Cinco de Mayo‍
Housewares Retail: Kitchen Focused Chains Still Thriving
Home Improvement: Harbor Freight and Ace Hardware Drive Outperformance through Smaller Markets
Home Furnishing: 2024 Outlook for Housewares, Mattress, and Furniture Retail
Happy Hispanic Heritage Month! Popularity of Hispanic Grocery Underlines Growing Appetite for Latin Foods
Holiday 2024: Time is of the Essence
Hispanic Grocery: Customizing the Merchandise Assortment to the Neighborhood
Happy Nowruz! Celebrating Persian New Year with a Tour of Tehrangeles
Happy Lunar New Year Part 2: Vietnamese, Korean, and Pan-Asian Malls
Gifting, Paper and Books: Consumers Crave More in One Place
Golf's COVID Comeback: PGA Superstore Reaping the Benefits
GEN Korean BBQ House: IPO Filing Underpins the Importance of Experiential Dining
Formula 1: U.S. Grand Prix Expansion Winning Key Visitor Segments
First Watch: Leading the Full-Service Breakfast Recovery
Equinox: What Price Would You Pay for Increased Longevity?
Fine Dining Restaurants: Is 6:00 PM Really the New 8:00 PM?
Dutch Bros: Data Reinforces Behavioral Trends, but Also Longer-Term Unit Goals
Elevated QSR Drive-Thru Formats: Do They Work?
Faherty: For Life's Great Moments
Dutch Bros: Innovation Driving Daypart Mix Changes; Long-Term Growth Plans On Track
Dodger Mania Boosts LA Economy During Run-Up to World Series