.svg)
Department stores continue to adapt to evolving consumer preferences and an ever-changing retail landscape. We looked at the latest location analytics for traditional and luxury department stores to uncover how they are finding success in today’s dynamic apparel space.
Off-Price Poses a Challenge
Consumers’ prioritization of value has significantly impacted the apparel space in recent years.
Fueled by tepid consumer confidence and rampant inflation, demand for off-price has soared, putting pressure on department stores and traditional apparel retailers. As a result, off-price’s share of total visits to the apparel space steadily increased between 2021 (36.4%) and 2024 (41.5%), while the visit shares of our traditional department stores and other apparel segments declined.
But luxury department stores, which serve a higher-income clientele, appear to have remained relatively insulated from the rise in budget-conscious shopping, as the relative share of visits to this segment held steady over the past four years.
Leaning into Value
Diving into cross-visitation trends also reveals the impact of a growing off-price segment on the department store space.
Between 2021 and 2024, the share of both Nordstrom’s and Dillard’s visitors that also visited one of the leading off-price chains increased – suggesting that shoppers at both traditional and premium department stores feel the draw of off-price apparel. (Still, the shares of Dillard’s visitors that also visited one of the off-price chains was generally larger than that of Nordstrom’s, suggesting that visitors to the more upscale department store were less inclined to also visit an off-price store.)
And it seems that leading department stores are already trying to meet the growing demand for discounts within their consumer base. Dillard’s emphasis on private-label merchandise helps keep products affordable without compromising quality. Meanwhile, Nordstrom continues to expand its off-price format – Nordstrom Rack – to capitalize on demand for value in the apparel space.
Delivering on Experience
Still, value-seeking behavior on the part of the consumer doesn’t always mean prioritization of discounts, and one way that several department stores are adding value – and finding success – is by investing in the shopping experience.
Bloomingdale’s emphasized experiential events and exclusive product launches to engage consumers last year, including several pop-culture-inspired collections. The department store’s visits increased 1.5% YoY in 2024, perhaps reflecting the demand for Bloomingdale’s immersive and culturally relevant environment.
Meanwhile, Nordstrom’s digital strategy demonstrated how a seamless omnichannel platform can elevate the shopping experience. The brand’s new app uses generative AI to make personalized style recommendations and allows users to check merchandise availability or make a stylist appointment at their local store. The app’s pre-holiday release may have contributed to Nordstrom’s resounding success in 2024, including a 2.2% visit increase compared to 2023.
And the investments in in-store experiences yielding visit dividends are not limited to premium chains. Dillard's, often considered a mid-range brand, has expert stylists ready to assist, and carefully manages inventory so stores are well-stocked but clutter-free, cultivating a classy retail environment. Dillard’s saw 2.3% YoY visit growth in 2024, indicating that its in-store experience is highly valued by shoppers.
The Department Store Opportunity
Department stores are uniquely positioned to thrive in the current apparel retail landscape. Faced with demand for lower price points, department stores can harness the opportunity with affordable private-label merchandise or off-price formats. And while value-seeking is on the rise, retailers that provide an elevated shopping experience add a different kind of value to their brand.
For more data-driven retail insights, visit Placer.ai.
