Fun Within Reach
2026 has been all about the affordable indulgence. And even as consumers tightened their purse strings, discount discretionary retailers Five Below and Ollie’s Bargain Outlet continued to expand their reach.
Yet while overall visits climbed at both chains, Five Below delivered significantly stronger same-store traffic gains – raising the question: What gave the trend-focused retailer an edge over its closeout rival?
Five Below Keeps Thriving
Five Below’s visits climbed 18.8% year over year (YoY) in Q3 2026, with same-store visits rising 9.8%. The chain, which opened its 2,000th store in July, continued bringing its affordable indulgences to more communities while also growing traffic at existing locations. The momentum held into the fall, with same-store visits up 10.5% and 8.4% in September and October, respectively.
For consumers watching their spending, Five Below’s mix of toys, beauty products, and other inexpensive finds offers an accessible way to treat themselves. And the chain has also benefited from this year’s collectibles craze – with viral products like Squishy Dumplings and licensed merchandise tied to Toy Story, Spider-Man, and KPop Demon Hunters drawing shoppers who go on to explore the rest of the store.
Ollie’s Gains Ground
Visits to Ollie’s also grew 14.0% YoY in Q3 as the chain continued opening new locations. And same-store visits remained in positive territory – no small feat for an expanding discretionary retailer at a time when high gas prices and stretched budgets are prompting shoppers to cut back on nonessential purchases.
Ollie’s more modest same-store visit growth may partly reflect its focus on higher-ticket merchandise. Unlike Five Below, where 80% of units sold are still for items that cost $5 or less, Ollie’s brand-name closeout model offers deep discounts on pricier items like mattresses, furniture, and even air conditioners – alongside smaller purchases like holiday decor, toys, and kitchen utensils. And bigger purchases may be easier to postpone when budgets tighten, potentially leaving Ollie’s more exposed to spending cutbacks than a retailer centered on small treats.
Five Below’s Proximity Advantage
The two chains’ different roles are also reflected in how far shoppers travel to visit them. In Q3 2026, just 26.9% of Five Below’s visits came from 10 or more miles away, compared with 32.5% for discretionary retail overall. Ollie’s, by contrast, drew 34.2% of visits from that distance, consistent with its role as a destination for bargain hunters seeking bigger-ticket deals.
Five Below’s more local draw may give it an edge as high gas prices discourage longer shopping trips. And its visitors also come from relatively higher-income areas, with a median household income of $79.0K compared with $69.6K for Ollie’s. Both figures fall below the nationwide median of $87.3K, but Five Below’s shoppers may have more room in their budgets for discretionary splurges.
Opportunity Ahead
Five Below and Ollie’s both continued expanding while growing visits to existing stores in Q3. But Five Below’s combination of affordable indulgences and a convenient local footprint appears especially well suited to shoppers looking to enjoy a little without spending a lot. Ollie’s, meanwhile, has continued to grow despite a challenging environment for bigger-ticket discretionary purchases – leaving it well positioned to regain momentum as economic conditions improve.
For more data-driven retail insights, visit Placer.ai/anchor.





.avif)
.avif)

.avif)
.avif)







