Room for Fun
This year has been all about affordable indulgences. Even as consumers tightened their purse strings, they continued looking for ways to treat themselves – and discount retailers like Five Below and Ollie’s Bargain Outlet benefited.
But while both chains expanded their footprints and enjoyed overall visit growth in Q3, Five Below posted significantly stronger same-store traffic gains. A closer look at the retailers’ different approaches to value helps explain why.
Five Below Keeps Thriving
Five Below’s visits climbed 18.8% year over year (YoY) in Q3 2026, with same-store visits rising a robust 9.8%. The momentum held into the fall, with same-store visits up 8.4% in October.
For consumers watching their spending, Five Below’s mix of toys, beauty products, and other inexpensive finds offers an accessible way to treat themselves. And the chain has also benefited from this year’s collectibles craze – with viral products like Squishy Dumplings and licensed merchandise tied to Toy Story, Spider-Man, and KPop Demon Hunters drawing shoppers who go on to explore the rest of the store.
Ollie’s Treasure Hunt Draws Shoppers
Visits to Ollie’s also grew 14.0% YoY in Q3 as the chain continued expanding, while same-store visits edged up 1.3% – a more modest gain than Five Below’s, but still an achievement in a challenging environment for discretionary retail.
The difference may partly reflect the chains’ distinct shopping models. While Five Below focuses on inexpensive treats and trendy finds, Ollie’s brand-name closeout model invites shoppers on a treasure hunt for deeply discounted merchandise, including higher-ticket items like mattresses, furniture, and even air conditioners. Its ever-changing assortment makes the hunt itself part of the appeal, giving shoppers a reason to return and see what new bargains they can find. But bigger purchases may be easier to postpone when budgets tighten – potentially contributing to the gap in same-store traffic growth.
Different Models, Different Shopping Trips
Five Below also likely benefits from its proximity advantage. In Q3 2026, just 26.9% of Five Below’s visits came from 10 or more miles away, compared with 32.5% for discretionary retail overall. Ollie’s, by contrast, drew 34.2% of visits from that distance – consistent with its appeal as a destination retailer. And with elevated gas prices discouraging longer shopping trips, Five Below’s more local draw may give it an added edge.
Five Below’s visitors also come from relatively higher-income areas, with a median household income of $79.0K compared with $69.6K for Ollie’s. Both figures fall below the nationwide median of $87.3K, but Five Below’s shoppers may have more room in their budgets for discretionary splurges.
Value Within Reach
Five Below’s combination of affordable indulgences and a convenient local footprint appears especially well suited to the 2026 shopper eager to treat themselves without overspending. Ollie’s, meanwhile, continues to attract bargain hunters with its distinctive treasure-hunt experience, even in a challenging environment for bigger-ticket discretionary purchases. How will the two retailers fare as the holiday shopping season kicks into high gear?
Follow Placer.ai/anchor to find out.





.avif)
.avif)

.avif)
.avif)







