Thanks for Visiting!

Register for free to get the full story.

Sign Up
Already have a account? Log In

Indoor vs. Open Air Malls - Who's Performing Better?

Ethan Chernofsky
July 1, 2020
Indoor vs. Open Air Malls - Who's Performing Better?

A common narrative during the COVID recovery period has been that indoor malls are facing a near existential crisis. To analyze the validity of this argument, we dove into ten of the top indoor malls and ten of the top outdoor centers to compare their relative performance in order to break down the pace of recovery and the potential for the coming months.

Visit Comparison

Obviously, indoor centers were harder hit than outdoor centers with visits having dropped to nothing by mid-March and continuing that way through late April. Outdoor centers benefitted from the essential retailers that were able to stay open, though in a very limited capacity. 

Yet, the pace of recovery for indoor centers has been far better than many expected. By the week of June 8th, visits to the centers analyzed were down 41.7% year-over-year compared to being down 74.6% the week of May 4th, just a little over a month earlier. And all this with malls in states like New York and California still closed during this period.

Outdoor shopping centers were performing better with a decrease of just 33.5% the week of June 8th, compared to being down 74.5% the week of May 4th. 

Engagement Metrics

Yet, visits aren’t the only critical measure of success. Indoor malls gain strength from the magnitude of visits they are able to generate. Visitors are generally willing to travel longer distances to a mall with the promise of having an experience that goes beyond just shopping. And if you’re willing to spend a long amount of time in a mall, the likelihood of multiple purchases, whether food, entertainment, apparel, or home goods, is significantly increased. 

The key measure of this magnitude is the visit duration, and while visits rates are typically longer in indoor centers, they are also returning closer to normal levels faster. 

Comparing visit durations the week of June 8th, with the week of March 9th - the last pre-pandemic week - shows indoor centers down just 9.2% while outdoor centers were down 15.8%. The latter is likely being impacted by shifts in consumer behavior that focus on more ‘mission-driven’ shopping that privileged longer visits to retailers with a wider product range at the expense of more visits to a number of locations -  and ultimately, a longer overall visit. However, this too could bounce back soon.


A third factor that can provide critical insights is the size of the True Trade Area these centers pull from. The ‘reach’ of a center helps define its addressable market, and the larger the True Trade Area, the larger a population a specific mall can pull from, helping to bring consistency to their visit rates. With restricted hours and only certain stores open, the ‘pull’ for indoor centers was limited during the early days of their reopenings, impacting the willingness of shoppers to travel farther distances.

Yet, here too, the size of these True Trade Areas are returning to ‘normal’. While the average True Trade Area size for indoor centers was still down 9.7% the week of June 4th compared to the week of March 9th, this reflected a True Trade Area size that was 41.1% larger than it was the week of May 11th.

Conclusions and Key Takeaways

Yes, the wider mall sector has been undergoing a significant change over the last few years. However, this does not mean that the fundamental value of the mall is decreasing. Rather, it is more likely that some of the means of driving success are changing, but this was a process already taking place long before the pandemic

Looking at these indexes of top centers shows that leading malls are recovering at a healthy pace, even with all of the uncertainty surrounding performance and the myriad of obstacles in their path. Does it guarantee success for all? No. Does it show that opportunities for players in this sector and demand from consumers still clearly exist? Absolutely.

On the other hand, it is difficult to argue with the newfound value that outdoor centers have received. Their ability to anchor around essential retail and the comfort that they can provide with a less enclosed experience should provide them strength so long as concerns of a second wave persist. Additionally, their orientation towards well-positioned retailers like off-price apparel, traditional grocers, home improvement brands, and more all help strengthen their current status.

However, the likeliest scenario is not one of dominance by indoor or outdoor centers, but an evolving landscape of retailers and tenants that look to take advantage of the unique benefits of either option. In fact, it’s very likely that an increasing number of brands will look to capitalize on the benefits of the forum they don’t currently dominate as a means of adding value and diversifying their reach. The key moving forward will be identifying the ideal way of differentiating and providing mechanisms to boost the specific strengths that each one offers.

Get 3 brand & industry
breakdowns every week

Subscribe to the newsletter

Great! Prepare your inbox for data-driven insights...
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Get a Demo

Please enter your first name
Please enter your last name
Please provide a valid email
Please enter your email
Please enter company name

Thanks for reaching out!

One of our experts will be in touch soon

Try Free
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Small Coffee Chains Brewing Big Success White Paper Recap – November 2023
Thanksgiving Travel 2023 Recap
Checking in With Nike and Lululemon
Black Friday 2023 Retail Recap
Starbucks’ 2023 Holiday Menu & Red Cup Day Performance
Turkey Wednesday 2023
Who Attended the 2023 Pickleball Championship? 
Three Surprising Holiday Shopping Trends
What’s in Store for Ulta Beauty This Holiday Season?
Best Buy and Department Stores: A Holiday Deep Dive
Discount & Dollar Stores: Strength Toward The End of the Year
The State of Off-Price Retail: Discounts Seal The Deal
Placer Mall Index Recap: October 2023 Office Index: October 2023 Recap
Retail Corridors Ahead of the 2023 Holiday Season
California, Here Gap Comes
Checking in With Home Improvement
Getting Into the Glasses Game: Warby Parker Takes Over
Fitness Positioned for a Strong 2023 Finish
White Paper Recap: October 2023
Coffee Giants Brewing Up Business
Popeyes and Burger King Lead the Way
Diving into Yum!
Looking Ahead to Black Friday 2023
Blockbusters Drive Movie Theater Comeback
Crocs and Boot Barn: Shoe-Ins for Success
McDonald’s and Chipotle's Winning Recipe
The State Of Steak: Checking in With Texas Roadhouse
Pleasant Pastimes: Pickleball Potential Proves Potent
Who’s Driving Downtown Manhattan’s Weekend Revival?
Diving into Downtown Manhattan Foot Traffic Trends
Rite Aid: Rightsizing Right
Major League Soccer: Its Die-Hard and Casual Fans
The Anchor Recap: September 2023 Office Index: September 2023 Recap
Placer Mall Index Recap: September 2023
September White Paper Recap
The Consumer Habits of College Students
JCPenney: Rightsizing and Revitalizing
Pent-Up Demand Ahead of October Sales Events
4 Strategies Retailers are Using to Drive Traffic to Their Venues
5 Key Regional Grocery Players Impressing in 2023
Upscale Kitchenware Trending Up
Costco Finds More Room for Growth
Four C-Store Chains Making an A-Grade
National Parks + Outdoor Summer Activities
Diving Into Darden: Summer 2023 Update
The Summer Event Effect
Messi: Massive in Miami
Looking Back on Back to School 2023
The Anchor Recap: August 2023 Office Index: August 2023 Recap Mall Index: August 2023 Recap White Paper Recap: August 2023
Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte Strikes Again
Big Scoop: We All Scream For Ice Cream
Sports Away: Lululemon & Nike’s Momentum Continues
Summer Visits Heat Up For Recreation and Outdoor Gear Chains
No CSS overwrite - July 2023 Office Index Recap
Staging - August 2023 Mall Indec
Mid-Atlantic Grocery Deep Dive
Experiential Chains Heating Up This Summer
Petco Goes Big by Going Small
Ulta Beauty: Leading the Discretionary Pack
Discount and Dollar Chains Continue to Thrive
Summer of Sports: DICK’s Sporting Goods and Hibbett Sports
Off-Price: Succeeding Into Summer
The Anchor Recap: July 2023
Superstores Maintaining Pandemic Gains Amidst Economic Headwinds
2023: Home Improvement at the Halfway Point
July 2023 Office Index Recap Mall Index: July 2023 Recap
The Taylor Swift Visit Lift
Southwestern Grocery Dive
July 2023 White Paper Recap: Halfway Point Review & Quarterly Index
Yum! Brands: Driving Dining Visits
Slurpees and Summer Movies Stimulate Consumer Foot Traffic
Cool Beans: Summer Coffee Update
Checking In on Back to School 2023
Crocs and New Balance Tip The Scales
Burger Bliss: Shake Shack and In-N-Out Stacking Visits
Chipotle & McDonald's Continue to Reign Supreme
Vibenomics and Partner to Enhance Retail Media In-Store Measurement
California Grocers Here We Come!
Marriott’s Different Audiences
Bonchon and Kura Sushi Thrive in the Fast-Casual Scene
A Shoe In: Footwear Climbs to the Top
Cheers! Raising a Glass to Beverage Retail Office Index: June 2023 Recap Mall Index June 2023 Recap – A Turn of the Tide and a Dive into Open-Air Lifestyle Centers
Local Kitchens: Redefining the Restaurant
Unlocking Urban Insights: The Value in Manhattan’s Employees
Ohio State Parks On The Rise
How is Inflation Impacting the High-Income Shoppers?
Five Fast-Growing Dining Chains
What To Expect From Prime Day and July Sales Events in 2023
The State Of Fashion: How Are Apparel Retailers Faring in 2023?
2023’s Latest Dining Success Story: GEN Korean BBQ House
The NBA Finals: A Location Intelligence Perspective