Thanks for Visiting!

Register for free to get the full story.

Sign Up
Already have a Placer.ai account? Log In

Why Is Walmart Closing Stores? A Placer.ai Data Deep Dive

by 
Zohar Bar-Yehuda
 on 
June 4, 2019
Why Is Walmart Closing Stores? A Placer.ai Data Deep Dive
  • Mobile data shows that not all store closings are the same
  • Top retailers are leveraging location analytics to maximize their store sites
  • True Trade Area data - the places where audiences actually come from - is critial for market planning efforts
  • Analyzing companies like Walmart and IKEA can indicate the trends that are strengthening offline retail

Walmart’s Closing Stores

Walmart has come under fire of late for announcing a series of store closures around the United States. Many of these closings have come from the Neighborhood Market brand focused on groceries, but several closures have come from Walmart’s flagship Supercenters.

While closures have become a frequent story in a changing retail environment, there is something uniquely interesting about a brand as strong as Walmart closing its signature stores.

To understand the situation better, we dove into location analytics to unpack the decision making and what it could potentially indicate moving forward.

Limited Reduction in Traffic

One of the first stores to have their closure announced was a Walmart Supercenter in Dallas, Texas. In a normal situation, one would expect to see underperforming stores suffer from a significant drop in foot traffic. Yet, the Dallas location was actually operating at fairly normal levels. The graph below shows weekly foot traffic to this location beginning in the first week of June 2017 until May 2019 when the store shut down.

Wider numbers also don’t align with a weak performer as the store enjoyed over 450,000 visits in Q1 2019 alone from over 150,000 visitors. So, not only are people coming to the store, they are coming frequently. Furthermore, comparing this branch against all Walmart Supercenters in the US, it is ranked at the 86th percentile in terms of foot traffic in Q1 2019, with traffic that’s almost 50% higher than the ‘average’ Walmart Supercenter:

Combining this activity with the rise of Buy Online Pick-up In Store, and it is surprising to see these locations shut.

Cannibalization

One possible answer comes from a risk that every major chain faces - cannibalization. Walmart’s strength has led to a rapid expansion of stores throughout the country, that in some cases, ended up putting stores into direct competition. For example, looking at the True Trade Area for the same Dallas location compared to two other nearby Walmart Supercenters highlights the challenge that the store faced. It was competing directly with two other centers with an almost complete overlap of customers. This means customers weren’t choosing whether or not to go to Walmart, but which Walmart to go to.

This factor was also substantial for two locations in Louisiana where a closed store - a Walmart Supercenter in Lafayette -  saw their audience overlapping almost completely with a Walmart Supercenter in nearby Carenco.

In short, Walmart is not undergoing some shocking reduction in brand value or customer loyalty, but customers are being served by multiple locations. The result is that a specific Walmart Supercenter’s biggest competitor turns out to be another Walmart Supercenter.

Why Does This Happen?

It is easy to look at cannibalization as a simple error to overlook, but in reality, the data available to retailers has been severely limited. Most are forced to make do with trade area data that focuses on the simple breakdown of a 3,5 or 7-mile radius. Yet, the reality is that customers are not limited to an arbitrary circle and are more likely to follow specific travel patterns based on traffic flow, proximity to workplaces and a myriad of other factors. As a result, major chains are often forced to make decisions in a deep fog leading to costly mistakes.

Can It Be Done Better?

Another question is whether cannibalization is simply guaranteed and unavoidable. But analyzing other top brands shows that market planning optimization can be achieved.

Take IKEA as an example. In the Greater Los Angeles area, there are four IKEA locations that surround the city. Each sells the same products, each offers the same level of service and each has a near identical rating on Google - three with 4.4 stars and the remaining with 4.3. But IKEA’s brilliance doesn’t lie in a fundamental difference within the store, but in the absolute perfection of the distance each property has from the other stores.

Even when accounting for 80% of overall visits over a 6 month period from late 2018 to mid-2019, the cannibalization between stores is almost non-existent. For the IKEA customer, it is obvious where they should go, because there is an ideal location and then there is everything else.

The result is an optimization of a region that helps each store maximize its area while enabling IKEA to grow at a sustainable rate.

Walmart’s Supercenter Path

To analyze Walmart’s situation further, we dove into several other locations where multiple Walmart Supercenters sit in relative proximity. The map below shows the True Trade Area of several locations around Fort Meyers, Florida. The locations marked with Blue and Red symbols see almost perfect delineation based on natural borders. Interestingly, while one section of the Red property’s trade area is untouched, it does have significant overlap with the property marked in green further East.

Could this indicate a value in relocating the Green site further to the East? Potentially. However, the separation of the sites marked in blue and red show the impact of optimizing location. Even though the sites are close in terms of distance, the natural barrier keeps cannibalization to a minimum.

The problem of cannibalization comes into greater focus as one moves north to another grouping of three Supercenters in the area of Bradenton, Florida. The three properties all have strong overlap, with the primary culprit coming from the location marked in Red. If you were leading Walmart’s market planning division and looking to maximize the value of each store, wouldn’t this be the ideal site to relocate? Audience patterns indicate that the other stores would effectively serve this market and costs could be limited.

Conclusions - The Rise of Offline Optimization

Not all store closures are equal.

Many brands are only now beginning to utilize tools that enhance their visibility and understanding of customer engagement. As a result, many actions - like store closings - need to be seen more as a reaction to new and accurate data than a decrease in brand value.

The impact of data-driven approaches that leverage location analytics cannot be overstated. It adds a powerful level of capabilities to large and small retailers alike looking to maximize their impact. Where digital companies have leveraged data to optimize their activities, the rise in solutions like Placer.ai has given companies the ability to deploy similarly data-driven approaches to the offline world.

Especially in the scope of the wider debate around the demise of brick and mortar retail, data like this can empower offline retailers to thrive in a changing retail landscape.

Get 3 brand & industry
breakdowns every week

Subscribe to the newsletter

Great! Prepare your inbox for data-driven insights...
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Get a Demo

Please enter your first name
Please enter your last name
Please provide a valid email
Please enter your email
Please enter company name

Thanks for reaching out!

One of our experts will be in touch soon

Try Placer.ai Free
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Why Are Specialty Grocers Thriving in 2023?
The CAVA Craze: A Location Intelligence Perspective on the Mediterranean Marvel
How Will Primark’s US Expansion Impact Target?
All Eyes on Eyewear
Northwestern U.S. Grocery Dive
Return of the Lunch: Salad Chains Are Thriving
Retail Media Networks – Off the Beaten Track
Bet Your Bottom Dollar: Discount and Dollar Stores Drive Foot Traffic
Ulta & Lululemon: Discretionary Spending On The Up
The Score After Q1: Sporting Goods Chains
Who Uses NYC Airports: Biting Into The Big Apple’s Main Transport Hubs
Off Price: Strength in The Face of Retail Challenges
Visits Improve for Home Improvement
Walmart, Target & Wholesalers in Q1 2023 – The Return of Mission-Driven Shopping?
Department Store Roundup: Q1 2023
Placer.ai Office Index: April 2023 Recap
Placer.ai Mall Index, April 2023 – A Rebound on the Horizon?
How Will Bed Bath & Beyond’s Bankruptcy Impact the Retail Space?
Buffet Restaurants: Filling Up on Foot Traffic
Thrift Stores: Vintage Visits Drive New Age in Apparel
The Windy City: A Hub of Post-Pandemic Opportunity
Diving into Dining Traffic - Q1 2023
Bring On The Joe
A Dollar (or more) For Your Thoughts: Five Below and pOpshelf
Dining Out With The Cheesecake Factory
Retail Foot Traffic Recap – March 2023
Digging Into 2023: McDonald’s and Chipotle Update
Placer.ai Office Index: March 2023 Recap
How Did Key Retail Categories Perform in Q1 2023?
Northeastern USA Grocery Dive
Movie Theaters Storylines for 2023
Ollie's Bargain Outlet: Discounters are Evolving
Leveraging Brick-and-Mortar Retail in 2023
America’s Evolving Work Patterns: A Deep-Dive into New York and Chicago
Placer.ai Mall Index March 2023
Tuning Into Record Stores
Five Franchises To Watch in 2023
What’s Next For Domestic Tourism?
It’s Showtime! Movie Theaters in the Spotlight
5 Limited Time Offers (LTOs) Driving Restaurant Traffic
Department Store Deep-Dive: Belk
Regional Grocery Chains Staying Ahead of the Competition
Five Chains that Rightsized for Success
Unlocking the Potential of Offline Retail Media Networks
Dining Out With Darden
What’s in Store for Self-Storage?
Nike & lululemon Update: Strong Performance Amid Expansion Plans
Many Ways to Win: Midwest Grocery Deep Dive
Retail, Reinvented: The Rise of the Pop-Up Shop
Navigating a New Normal in Business Travel & Commutes
Placer.ai Office Index: February 2023 Recap
Retail Categories Staying Strong in Volatile Environment
Ulta Beauty: Poised for Success into 2023
Placer.ai Mall Index February 2023: Reasons for Continued Optimism
Catching Up With DICK’s & Hibbett
The Miami-Dade Arena: An Advertising Slam Dunk
Car Washes Revving Up Visits
Tuesday Morning and Sunrises in Home Furnishing
Dining & Valentine’s Day Recap
2023: The Year of the Discount Store
Aldi’s Success Highlights Growing Demand for Value Groceries
5 Retail & Service Categories Holding onto Pandemic Gains in 2023
Visitor Insights from Super Bowl 2023
2023 First Look: Home Improvement Update
How Are Target, Walmart, and Wholesale Clubs Faring in 2023?
Department Store Deep-Dive: Nordstrom
Off-Price: Taking Off in Uncertain Times
Checking in On Middle-Class Hubs
Who Attends the Super Bowl?
Placer.ai Office Index: January 2023 Recap
Focusing On Fitness: Q4 and January Recap
Placer.ai Mall Index: January 2023 – Returning Mall Normalcy?
Location Intelligence Insights Into Concert Attendance
Winning Dining Strategies for 2023
In-N-Out Burger: What to Expect as the Brand Moves East
Location Intelligence Breakdown: Coffee Caps-Off 2022
Digitally Native Brands Lean Into Brick & Mortar
Washington, D.C. Population Changes & Migration Trends
A Location Intelligence Perspective on Macy’s Rightsizing
Amazon-Powered Shopping: The Future of Brick-and-Mortar Grocery?
Cold Weather, Hot Visits: Diving into Winter Resorts
Wawa and 7-Eleven: Leaning Into the “Slurpee Effect”
2022 and Beyond: Catching Up With McDonald’s & Chipotle
Let’s Have Some Fun! Going Out Is In
Placer.ai’s Q4 2022 Quarterly Index
Placer.ai Adds Industry Executives to Leadership Team To Drive Company's Next Phase of Growth
5 Emerging Retail Formats: 2023’s Brick-and-Mortar Evolution
Grocery Update: Zooming in on the Lone Star State
2022 Office Recap: The Year of the TGIF Work Week
What Lies Ahead for Brick-and-Mortar Luxury in 2023
Placer.ai Mall Indexes: December 2022 Recap
Looking Back on 2022’s Holiday Shopping Season
Post-Pandemic Migration Trends in New York
Top Retailers for 2023
The Live Sports Advertising Opportunity
Domestic Migration to the Mountain States: Small Shifts with Big Implications
New Year, New Food: 5 Dining Trends For 2023
Announcing Placer.ai’s COVID RECOVERY DASHBOARD
This is Why Shop-in-Shops Are Everywhere
Super Saturday 2022 Recap